Which of the following diagnostic tools is more predictive in permanent teeth?

The Cariogram has been evaluated and found to be more predictive in permanent teeth than with preschool children.  The “Cariogram” is a computed caries-risk program that records several data points including past caries experience, diet, oral hygiene habits, fluoride exposures, and analysis of saliva. The program then produces the results as a colored graph. This was well described by Gonzalez and Okunseri in 2010.  The different colors are as follows: red for bacteria, dark blue for diet, light blue for susceptibility-related factors, and yellow for the circumstance.